Electrophoretic Method Adapted for Separating
Microbes
Faced with an expanding array of products such as probiotics that
contain live bacteria, it behooves those who handle them and may be
responsible for certifying their content and quality to have quick and
accurate tests to determine species, strain, and percentage of viable
microorganisms in a particular product. Recently, Dan Armstrong and his
team of chemists at Iowa State University in Ames adapted capillary zone
electrophoresis (ZE) and isoelectric focusing (IF) methods to this
purposeproviding a new, rapid, and efficient analytic means for
separating a wide range of microorganisms, including bacteria, yeasts,
and viruses.
Although used extensively for separating and analyzing biological
macromolecules such as DNA and proteins, capillary ZE and IF methods
were not previously applied to microbes, which typically are at least
100- to 1,000-fold larger than such molecules. These methods separate
particles such as cells or molecules on the basis of size, shape,
electrical charge, and their interaction with various additives that may
be supplied to the analytic medium. Conditions, including pH and buffer
type, are tinkered with to encourage particular microbes to migrate as
single peaks during an analytic run.
According to Armstrongs high-efficiency microbial separation
(HEMS) method, capillary tubes with internal diameters of 50 to 100
microns can replace the traditional slab gel used for many kinds of
electrophoresis-based analysesshort-circuiting the time-consuming and
thus costly step needed to prepare this workhorse of many analytical
laboratories. The alternative capillary-based "miniaturized
electrophoresis" procedure uses samples consisting of a mere few
microliters, and bacteria or other microorganisms typically remain
viable throughout the analytic process, according to Armstrong. Because
a routine analysis may last only 10 to 15 minutes, HEMS lends itself to
real-time monitoring and high-throughput screening.
Armstrong stumbled on the idea for adapting capillary ZE and IF
analytic methods to separating microorganisms about eight years ago
while he was exploring ways to separate gram-positive and gram-negative
bacteria. Exploiting the capacity of the antibiotic vancomycin to bind
gram-positive bacteria, he initially used this antibiotic-binding
property to develop a capillary zone electrophoresis method for
separating these two broad classes of bacteria. "That led to this
more general approach," he says.
For example, early this year, Armstrong and his collaborators
published a report describing how they used HEMS to separate, identify,
and quantitatively measure Lactobacillus acidophilus, which is
advertised as the active component of a widely used dietary supplement
for individuals with lactose intolerance (FEMS Microbiology Letters,
January 1, 2001). As an adjunct to the HEMS procedure, they also
determine cell viability by pretreating cells with a mixture of green
and red fluorescent stains that cause viable cells to glow green while
dead cells appear red under a dual- channel laser. Their analysis of the
dietary supplement indicated that only about 60% of L. acidophilus
cells in a popular commercial brand are viable.
In addition to verifying the content of probiotics, HEMS also holds
promise for quickly identifying pathogens involved in causing
infections, such as those of the urinary tract, according to Armstrong.
In a few microliters of urine and without pretreating specimens,
"we can check for all likely bacteria simultaneously," he
says. The method is faster and cheaper than waiting days for bacterial
cultures to grow, or using PCR-based probes, each of which is designed
to identify only one type of bacteria.
Armstrong also predicts that HEMS will find wide use in the food and
biotechnology industries to monitor fermentation processes for producing
pharmaceuticals, food additives, or other products that contain live
microorganisms. "Theres no way to look at microbes
directly" he says. Instead, fermentation processes typically are
followed by monitoring the amount of product generated or the decline of
starting materials. HEMS can also detect contaminants and microbes
containing mutations. "In the next five to ten years, well see
hundreds of people leaping into this useful technology," he
predicts. Faced with keen interest from companies and venture
capitalists who may help in commercializing the HEMS procedure, he adds,
"were trying to decide the best way to go."
Carol Potera
Carol Potera is a freelance writer based in Great Falls, Mont.