Application of Anammox for Nitrogen Removal from
Wastewater
Figure 1
Right from the start of our research into the exciting Anammox process,
support was provided by the Netherlands Foundation for Applied Science (STW)
and the Foundation of Applied Water Research (STOWA) together with
industry, because the possible application of the anammox process in
wastewater treatment had obvious advantages and might lead to very
considerable savings in terms of energy and operational costs for nitrogen
removal.
Conventional procedures for removal of ammonium from waste water make
use of the well known nitrification/denitrification process according to
the following aerobic/anaerobic reactions (1) (3):
Aerobic nitrification
NH4+ + 1.5 O2à
NO2- + H2O + 2H+ (1)
Aerobic nitrification
NO2- + 0.5 O2à
NO3- (2)
Heterotrophic denitrification
6 NO3- + 5 CH3OH + H+ à
3 N2+ 5 HCO3-+ 8 H2O (3)
Anoxic ammonium oxidation (Anammox)
NH4+ + NO2- à
N2 (4)
Combined nitritification and anammox
2 NH4+ + 1.5 O2 à
N2 + 3 H2O + 2 H+ (5)
The nitrification proceeds in two steps by nitrifying bacteria such as
the ammonium-oxidizing Nitrosomonas or Nitrosospira species
(1) and the nitrite-oxizing Nitrobacter or Nitrospira species
(2), whilst the denitrification takes place under anoxic conditions by a
large variety of bacteria using a variety of organic compounds as the
electron donor. In reaction (3) this is exemplified by methanol used in
the daily practice of wastewater treatment when no other cheap carbon
source is available. The disadvantage of this process (1)-(3) is the
relatively high (energy-) cost for aeration (total of 2 O2
required per ammonium) and methanol. Introduction of the Anammox reaction
(4) in combination with partial oxidation to nitrite (1) will allow
reaction (5) that can save oxygen because only half of the ammonium needs
to be oxidized to nitrite. Most importantly, the Anammox reaction will
totally replace methanol use. In the earlier stage of the development of
the Anammox process for practical application it was feared that the slow
growth of the responsible bacteria such as Candidatus Brocadia
anammoxidans would become an unsurmountable problem. However the research
in Delft in collaboration with Mark van Loosdrecht and Udo van Dongen now
has shown that extremely high biomass (20-40 kg of dry weight per m3)
densities can be grown in systems with very efficient biomass retention.
These systems possess very high volumetric loading rate (2-8 kg of N
converted per m3 per day) competitive to aerobic nitrification.
The Anammox process is particularly suited for wastewaters that contain
high ammonium and little organic compounds (COD), such as sludge digestors
effluent and a variety of industrial wastewaters. It is estimated that
this may lead to reduction in operational cost by a factor of 10.
Feasibility studies on a 20-liter scale with sludge digestor effluent have
shown that the composition of the influent did not negatively affect the
ammonium removal efficiency. The nitrogen load of the Anammox reactors
could be increased from 0.2 kg N m-3 day -1 to 2.6
kg N m-3 day-1 over 1 year. Over the years,
different types of processes have been patented. In one of these processes
the aerobic reaction (1) is applied under the name SHARON (single reactor
system for high ammonium removal over nitrite, now in operation on 1,800-m3
scale) to convert about 50% of the ammonium to nitrite without the need of
any pH control or biomass retention. The effluent is then fed into a
second reactor with Anammox to obtain anaerobic reaction (4), as shown in
the figure. Cost estimates are $ 0.70 kg-1 N, which is low
compared to the $ 2-5 kg-1 N calculated for other processes
tested on a pilot scale for the same purpose.
The discovery that the Anammox process, though anoxic, can very well be
run under oxygen limitation, also allowed the use of a single reactor to
convert ammonium to dinitrogen gas in the CANON reaction [completely
autotrophic N-removal over nitrite, (1) + (4) à
(5)]. Difference of this reaction with other processes such as Oland
and aerobic deammonification is that the latter two make use of
the denitrification activity of conventional aerobic nitrifiers instead of
Anammox used in the CANON system.
The first full-scale Anammox reactor in the Netherlands for the
treatment of the ammonium-rich water from sludge digestor is planned early
2001.